Topic: ***Why did this manga made me cry??***

[Ichigo100_otaku]

Thanks to Mizuki-sensei for this series
To all : I share with all of you that feeling . This serie has seem to be made me crying . . . But I did'nt cry, I want to contact with Mizuki-sensei to ask something after all

P/S : I'm a fan of Aya Toujo, you know, I'm very supprise about the ending !!!
(Sorry about my English)

[robbie spina]

make, why did this manga make you cry

[naruto_macken]

Yeah this manga is quite good
my girlfriend like it too
Hurray for Nishino

[stormsea7]

yeah me too, this is the first time i get so emotionally into a manga

however, the reson we all become like this...i think its because if u take the ecchi stuff away, u r like reading a novel, a highschool romantic love novel

if u really read through the manga, there is no reason not to be emotionally attach to it. i mean what started out as a bright, comedy, manga rose to it climax than come to dead halt, shattering all expectation at the ending.

[banzemanga]

Yeah, really good indeed. Besides, i don't think that it will work out completely fine if there weren't ecchi stuff - after all our lives involves them. Also many romantic turning points were thanks to some of the ecchi parts.

Now, about crying - i cried more than once and cried few times even though it was to read it again and knowing what was going to happen.

I belive that the most emotional parts were:

-if i had the courage, we would have been together
-rejecting the first person who stole your heart at first sight
-rejecting someone you still love but having to decide between what is right and wrong
-leving the person you love for her own good, so that she could archive her dreams

There were few more but don't remmeber

[NickZ]

This manga pulled out our emotion...
2 Thumbs up for Mizuki Kawashita!!!

[xlsacreddragonlx]

This manga made me cry because I loved Toujo Aya just that much. Although I wish she were real, I felt sad everytime she was sad and I felt happy whenever she was happy. Whenever she cried, I felt I wanted to cry as well (though I didn't actually cry, I felt like I wanted to). Goes to show how into the story I was.

[suhwa]

yea i didnt cry but i got pretty emotional...well dat damn manaka made my lovely Nishino sad in da manga... well i cant belame him cuz shes da 1 who broke up wit him so...w/e im lil upset cuz dis manga was 1 of da better mangas i read n it has finally ended.. i really wish it didnt end like dis cuz dat endin was fucked up well w/e it made nishino happy so its all good den

[buknoy]

yeah me too...it made me cry!! T___T Waah..why cant Manaka have three or four hearts!! I was moved by this manga so much that now im inlove with Aya!! waaah...i was just surprised bout the ending cause i want Aya-chan to be happier. T_T

[Roan]

I didn´t cry but i can assure this is the best manga of this type i have ever read, this manga was so touching and not to mention that made me laugh like hell
there were times like in the end where i wanted to cry

I would really like to greet Misuki sama

[Bertu]

I just finished reading I''s, and now I completely understand a less than favourable post by Motoko-chan.

Compared to I''s, Ichigo sucks big time and it is just a little bit from completely plagiarized, I'm glad I read it before I''s, so I enjoyed both.

I''s had the incredible effect of completely erasing the bad taste from Ichigo's ending and uplifting my mood. Man, I'm reading it for the second time!

PD both main characters from I''s kick the respective asses of the analogous ones from Ichigo, specially character construction, credibility, and developement. Now THIS manga made me cry... 

[Kaze101]

i thought ichigo 100% was better than I''s but just by a bit.
Although the I''s ending made me cry and the ichigo's ending didnt >_<; but ichigo's ending was powerful too.

[nishino fan]

 
junpei is so bad and he cannot decide which girl that he like.
it is also he hurt my nishido heart!

[Bertu]

Well, mover by the good impression caused by I''s I just finished same author's classic "Video Girl Ai".

 

You can officially call me a Manga crybaby now... as long as the manga is good.

[mycroftlee]

...i nearly cry because i envy junpei so much.. if only i would hav all of those attention..... ha,ha.. really, I's was really a good manga too, though i prefer ichigo ending...